Jaal (2012)-Bengali Movie Review

Jaal Bengali Movie PosterMar 5, 2012 (Calcutta Tube): Jaal is a 2012 Bengali movie directed by Amit Samanta with , Pamela, Rohan, Victor Banerjee, Sumanta Mukhopadhyay, Shilajit and others in the cast. Read the Bengali film review at Calcutta Tube.


Banner: Rasa Productions

Direction: Amit Samanta

Music: Ashok Raj

Lyrics: Goutam Susmit

Story, screenplay and dialogue: Somnath Bhattacharya

D.O.P.: Rana Dasgupta

Editor: Rabiranjan Moitra

Art Direction: Samir Kundu

Cast: Tanvir, Pamela, Rohan, Victor Banerjee, Santu Mukherjee, Sumanta Mukhopadhyay, Anuradha Ray, Shilajit and Masud Akhrar

Date of Release: 17th February 2012

Rating: 02/10

The story writer and director of Jaal seem to have conspired to make a film that will keep the audience busy trying to find out who loves who for what and who is killing who and why. It takes a cue from Kuch Kuch Hota Hai only to detract from the beaten-to-death plot to indulge in a series of murders. But these killings, says the story, are not by a serial killer. The killings – believe it or not – are sort of justified by explaining away this murderous instinct triggered by lack of love. If this rationale were to be officially accepted, the country would not need criminal justice or criminal law at all. This would save a lot on our national budget and reduce the tax burdens on the ordinary citizen. Besides, like some thriller serials on the small screen, the police inspector Agnidev Chatterjee arrives after several murders have already been committed.

Going back to Kuch Kuch Hota Hai, we have three young characters, Abir, his childhood best friend Ayesha and Rai, the girl he loves and wants to marry. He does not care that Ayesha is deeply in love with him or that his father wants him to marry Ayesha. He walks off to be with Rai only to come back when Ayesha tries to commit suicide. She is reduced to a paraplegic as a consequence of the failed suicide attempt. Soon after, Rai’s father tells him that Rai is suffering from terminal brain tumour. It is a lie but Abir is not aware so he rushes back to Rai. The way he flits across from Rai to Ayesha and back would make you wonder about what makes these two girls so besotted with a shaky man who can never make up his mind and is stupid enough to shift loyalties with one call for ‘help’.  The secret lies in the visuals Abir presents. Tanvir who portrays Abir is very good in the looks department and you know how crazy young girls can go with eye-candy looks in the opposite sex. It is basic in the law of human nature.

Suddenly, from nowhere, the killings begin. The killer’s identity is hidden with his/her black robes and hood and shoes and the works. But it does not really matter because he does not belong. Abir’s father is bumped off first followed by Rai’s father. Agnidev has no clue where to look for this robed person. When he does, the killer is shot dead and Ayesha who comes in the way is also killed! So many deaths in a triangular love story do not make sense. But who said the director wanted to make a sensible film?

Pamela who plays Ria and is known for her ready-to-shed-clothes image wears a strategically placed tattoo to add to her sex appeal. Does it? See the film and draw your conclusions. Shilajit has been given two catch lines the way N.K. Salil created catch phrases for Mithun Chakraborty. The director deserves a pat on his back for having cast Shilajit in an against-the-grain character because he is usually given a negative slant. He more than justifies the director’s choice.

It is not worth bothering about other technicalities such as music, cinematography, editing and art direction. It is sad to see that talented winners of music reality shows like Aneek Dhar, Sujoy and Anwesha’s voices are being used in films that are pulled off the theatres within the first week of their release.

– Shoma A. Chatterji

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *